The Beach House
No address
PO Box 648
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
631-749-0264

"A hidden treasure." That's how New York Magazine referred to this tranquil inn located on 200' of private beach overlooking Shelter Island Sound. With expansive water and sunset views, each of the guestrooms is decorated in simple uncluttered country style. Under the same ownership and management since 1985. Lodging is by reservation only, and is not suitable for children under 14 years of age.

Stearns Point House
7 Stearns Point Road
PO Box 648
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
631-749-4162

A traditional farmhouse only a five minute walk to Shelter Island's most beautiful beach. Located on a quiet country road. In this inn, all of the bright, sunny guest rooms have private baths, air conditioning, and either king or queen sized beds as well as comfortable wicker seating areas. Children of all ages are very welcome, and we also lodge canine friends on prior notice.

Call for More Information and Reservations
Lord of the Manor
Shelter Island Today

Designed by Shillingburg & Associates